Jim McMahon and I have no love between us. Indeed there has been no peace obtained in our many disagreements. That said, sometimes there is an issue that demands unity, even among bitter rivals. The closing of the Bon Secours maternity unit is one such issue.
I live on the borders of 2nd and 4th ward, the two wards that, combined, account for about 61 percent of all crime in Port Jervis and are home to most of our economically disadvantaged. Yesterday I learned that another of our teenage girls, a tenth grader, is pregnant.
With some of the highest teen pregnancy rates and pre-term births in Orange County*, it's almost criminal that these girls will have no local hospital to care for them or their children. So, when I received McMahon's email asking if I would post a link to the petition he started, I took a few moments to consider and then I signed the petition and agreed to post the link.
I encourage everyone reading to sign as well...
please click here.
- Steve
* Source: Orange County Community Health Assessment 2010-2013
from the Times Herald-Record
Port Jervis maternity unit closing
Bon Secours says demand is dwindling
The maternity unit at Bon Secours Community Hospital in Port Jervis will close next year, due to the dwindling number of births.
Officials from Bon Secours Charity Health System, the hospital's parent company, say there aren't enough deliveries per year to sustain the Center for New Life Birthing Unit. They announced the news earlier this month and expect the unit to close in about 120 days.
"It's never easy to exit a service line," said CEO Philip Patterson, "but it's a quality issue."
In 2009, Bon Secours Community delivered 238 babies, according to state data. On average, births at the hospital haven't exceeded 170 a year in the past three years, hospital officials said.
In filing the certificate of need for the closure to the state, hospital officials said they referenced a stipulation that 600 births a year is the preferred threshold for a quality program, a standard they say the state Department of Health held in the past.
15 nurses displaced
A spokesman for the state Health Department, reached Monday afternoon, was unable to confirm that such a standard is in effect.
While the numbers have been declining for years, hospital officials believe the death last year of longtime obstetrician Dr. Stanley Brunn, who delivered generations of babies, was a contributing factor in the recent drop.
A committee formed last year to determine the hospital's next steps recommended taking a year to see if the numbers increase or if the hospital is successful in recruiting new obstetricians. The committee met again in August, and after seeing no change, recommended the closure.
"We had to make a tough decision," Patterson said.
Fifteen nurses will be displaced by the closure, but officials hope to find them other jobs within the health system.
Officials are also working to redirect pregnant moms to St. Anthony Community Hospital in Warwick, also owned by Bon Secours Charity, and Orange Regional Medical Center in the Town of Wallkill. But that means moms in labor might have to travel an additional half hour or more to get to the hospital for delivery.
Longer trips for some patients
That might prove a major hardship for Margaret and Joseph Flood of Port Jervis. Margaret, 30, is six months pregnant with her seventh child. When her other children were born, she relied on her family and friends to get her to the hospital, since she doesn't own a car. Now that she might have to travel farther, she doesn't know what she's going to do.
"I don't know how I would get there," said Margaret, a patient at the Middletown Community Health Center's outpatient women's health services clinic in Port Jervis. "I can't believe (the hospital) would close it."
Community Health Center CEO Theresa Maloney said the center will continue its commitment to the Port Jervis community, even without Bon Secours Community's maternity unit. Its obstetricians have credentials at Orange Regional, and Maloney said she and her staff will make sure patients can get to Wallkill, even if it means lining up ambulances or taxis.
"We're doing everything possible to support the community and the OB/GYN program," she said. "We'll do whatever it takes to get the patient into care."